Menu of Antigoni’s Pizza Scarborough in Scarborough, Maine, USA

Menu Overview

Antigoni’s Pizza Scarborough, located conveniently at 172 US-1 in Scarborough, ME, is a standout destination for pizza lovers and casual diners alike. This family-owned pizza restaurant has quickly earned a loyal following for its fresh, flavorful offerings and friendly atmosphere. Having explored their menu, I can confidently say it delivers much more than just excellent pizza—it offers a well-rounded Italian-American dining experience.

The heart of Antigoni’s menu is, of course, their pizza, which has garnered rave reviews for its crispy crust, tasty sauce, and generous toppings. Customers like Rheana Roberts praise the wings alongside the pizza, highlighting a perfect pairing for any visit. The presence of a drive-through window enhances convenience, making it easy to enjoy their fresh-made pizzas on the go without compromising quality.

Beyond pizza, Antigoni’s excels with its variety of pasta dishes. The Eggplant Parmesan Pasta is a delightful vegetarian option, combining marinara sauce, tender eggplant, and cheese with perfectly cooked spaghetti. Similarly, the Chicken Parmesan Pasta delivers that classic comfort food feel, rich with marinara and melty cheese layered over tender chicken. The Grilled Veggie Pasta stands out with its medley of mushrooms, broccoli, onions, green pepper, and tomato, offering a vibrant and healthy choice for those seeking vegetable-forward meals.

For those craving hearty, cheesy comfort, the Macaroni and Cheese is homemade and satisfying, and the Stuffed Shells, available with your choice of Alfredo or marinara sauce, offer a rich, flavorful bite. Antigoni’s appetizers also deserve mention: their Buffalo Wings and Chicken Fingers are crispy, well-seasoned, and come with flavorful dipping sauces. The Appetizer Special is a great sampler, combining fries, mozzarella sticks, wings, and fingers—a perfect start to any meal or a sharing plate for groups.

Customer experiences emphasize not only the delicious food but also the welcoming service and clean, well-maintained space. Andy Martin’s observation about the friendly staff and smooth online ordering experience further underscores Antigoni’s commitment to customer satisfaction. Veteran food lovers in the Greater Portland area, like Pandika Pleqi, appreciate the legacy and warmth of this family business, making it more than just a pizza stop but a genuine community fixture.

In summary, Antigoni’s Pizza Scarborough offers an impressive menu with standout dishes across pizzas, pastas, and appetizers. The quality ingredients, diverse options, and thoughtful presentation make it a must-try for locals and travelers passing through. Whether you stop by for a quick drive-thru pick-up or a sit-down meal, the consistently tasty food and friendly atmosphere make every visit rewarding.